tirsdag den 25. oktober 2011

Thank You for Smoking.

Today I watched the film, 'Thank You for Smoking', with my lovely IT class students. It is meant to kick off our new theme, which is Consumerism. I have seen the film before, but it is always a pleasure, and today was no exception.

In my opinion, the film is both entertaining, as well as thought provoking. The issue of smoking and its consequences is of course a serious one, but as I see it humour should also deal with serious things. Furthermore, it serves as an excellent lesson in rhetoric!
If you care to look more closely, you can also find a lot of interesting details. For example, the usage of abbreviations (RAV/SAFETY), symbols of power - such as the Washington monument, wealthy white men with servants and pretty women.
An extra bonus, is the, albeit critical, insight into the American political system and society.

Now, I would like to encourage my students to write their own opinion of the film in the form of comments to this blog.

So 2b, what is your opinion?

11 kommentarer:

  1. In my opinion, I think the movie is very entertaining, crossing that point were it gets annoying, because I dont think smoking is great for us, as Nick Nayor express. The movie also gets a little mind thinking because when Nick Naylor is ''performing'' in his son's class, he tells the kids that it's okay to smoke, but he tells it in a kind of negative way. I agree up to a point that he is sending his message of smoking, because it is business. I cant just go to McDonalds and say: ''You need to close this business chain, in cause of obesity and health issues''. I see Nick's point of view for smoking, when he take part in these conferences, he can find more issues such as smoking (when he comes up with the examples from flight, and cars at the confrence).

    In my final conclusion of the movie, I think it was a great and entertaining movie, which shows that people need to take responsibilty to them selves refering to cigarettes.

    SvarSlet
  2. I think that the movie is great! It gives us a completely new view of business. Normally we – every day person – get the point of view as the costumers or just an outside view. But this movie gives us the view of the people who sells cigarettes. We get their point of perspective and ideas. We see how spin-doctors effect their speeches to the public (the press mostly), and how business can work. Thus, the producers use humor in the movie which makes it even better!
    The movie is good because it gives us another angle because we see it from the companies side, the victims side, instead of only our own.

    SvarSlet
  3. I think that the movie is great! It gives us a completely new view of business. Normally we – every day person – get the point of view as the costumers or just an outside view. But this movie gives us the view of the people who sells cigarettes. We get their point of perspective and ideas. We see how spin-doctors effect their speeches to the public (the press mostly), and how business can work. Thus, the producers use humor in the movie which makes it even better!
    The movie is good because it gives us another angle because we see it from the companies side, the victims side, instead of only our own.

    SvarSlet
  4. From my point of view the film, Thank you for smoking, is both humorous and serious. It deals with important issues such as smoking, drinking and firearms certificates.
    In my opinion, this works really well because, the film makes you reflect and at the same time it’s entertaining.
    I like that the story is told from Nick Naylor’s point of view, because it gives an idea of how hard it is to work for a company, which is making products that are hazardous.
    Despite of his job as a spin-doctor for a smoke company, Nick teaches his son that other people’s opinions doesn’t matter, as long as he is happy, with what he is doing.
    I agree up to a point, but it surely depends on what the company is producing, e.g. if a company is making products that are dangerous for the world, such as bombs and weapon. I would never justify such a company, or learn to understand people who do.

    Altogether the film was good, it made me reflect on the dilemma between what is right and wrong when you are choosing a career, after all you represent the company you work for.

    SvarSlet
  5. I think it was a very good movie. I enjoyed myself, because it was also a funny movie. But it was also a serious movie; it had a very important message. And the message was that money isn’t everything in live. The main character Nick, he worked for a cigarette company, but eventually does he change his mind. And he didn’t defend cigarettes anymore, he said that is dangerous for our health. Nick also tries to be a role model for his son during his time as the big tobacco’s chief spokesman.
    But I think it’s a very funny satirical comedy and I will highly recommend it to other people.

    SvarSlet
  6. I absolutely agree in, that the movie Thank you for smoking, is both serious and humorous, which they manage to keep with a fine balance in-between!
    You’re really getting the image of that smoking are a big health issue, and how much harm it really does to the society! But still the movie manages to keep the story simple and still highlight the point, that smoking isn’t healthy. And as far as I am concerned; that’s the most important! And that’s why I would say that the movie is great. Plus you also get to see things like, the Washington monument as you mentioned Angela, which is a pleasure for people who are just a bit interested in art, as I would call it.

    SvarSlet
  7. In my opinion, I think the movie is very interesting and very special because it takes the subject up about smoking. From my point of view it is a very dangerous and sensitively subject to make a film about, and that is why it is so provocative. Nick Naylor is the spokesman of cigarettes, he defends them and he is good at it. I agree up to one point that he is doing all this because it is his job, and “to pay the mortgage”, but when I says to his sun class that they have to find out by themselves whether smoking is good or bad for them, I think he cross the line.
    I do not agree at all, when Nick express that smoking is healthy, as I see it, smoking is really dangerous, and very bad for your organs. Even though the cigarettes saved Nick in the movie, I think it is a really bad argument to smoke.

    After all I think the movie is very good, it gives food for thought and I like movies that you think about after you have seen it.

    SvarSlet
  8. As I see it the movie makes a clear picture of advertising in modern society. It all comes down to how you present you product to the crowd, even if it’s a bad product or a good one. I think the film is absolutely right when they are showing us the battle between the scientist and the corporations, because the movie shows that if you just have the right arguments you can quickly changes peoples mind, and make them believe, in this cause, that smoking isn’t that bad for you. So from my point of view the movie creates a very real scenario and this could absolutely be a true story about getting throw to people in the modern world we live in today.

    SvarSlet
  9. Thank you for smoking – opinion assignment.
    Thomas Andersen 2.b
    I personally founded this movie rather funny. The story of a man, speaking on behalf of the cigarettes but still trying to remain a role model for his son is quite cliché though. This is a problem of whether he should choose his career or his family, and as it most often goes he chooses his family. But even though the plot was a bit cliché the movie was well written, and could with ease be mixed with an authentic story. Another important message was sent to people; don’t trust blindly in people that you don’t fully know. As of that I speak of the reporter the main character Nick Nayler slept with, and leaked out secret information about his company, and the “gang” that he and two others has created. All in all I think it was a great movie, but it’s not a movie I will have to see to soon again.
    On a scale from 1-5 I’d give it ★★★

    SvarSlet
  10. From Louise B.

    I like the movie. As I see it, it has a good point, and a good way to tell people, how a bad and unhealthy thing, as smoking, can be talked into a great and good thing. Nick used good arguments and manipulates people to see smoking as a good thing. It surprised me to see how our language and talent of using our voice had such a huge power. I do not agree with Nick Naylor at all, but he is such a good speaker that he actually make me think, that maybe it is not that bad at all? In my opinion the film is a little provoking because we follow Nick, and it is him we are supposed to take side with, but he is the person I disagree with, and that becomes a dilemma for me. In the film, he is shown like the good guy, but in my opinion he is not. It is wrong to tell people that something unhealthy is good for you, even if it is your job.

    After all I like the film, it deals with good subjects, and makes me think a lot about what is bad and what is good? What is wrong and what is right? It was both funny and serious, so altogether a very good movie.

    SvarSlet
  11. From Rebecca R.


    Thank you for smoking
    The movie is about a spokesman (Nick Naylor) who works in a tobacco factory. He tries to convince people that smoking isn’t dangerous – or the source of all diseases. Well I agree up to a point, but I’m afraid I can’t accept, that from the movies point of view, we automatically take his side. Because in real life, he would actually be the “bad” guy, trying to make people smoke. He also says that it’s not his responsibility to keep his son from cigarettes, but it’s the son’s choice to make, and get his own experiences. I do not agree at all, I think that when it comes to such a bad thing as smoking, you should keep your child away from it, and raise them not to do such things.

    SvarSlet